Scots lose sight of early release offenders due to faulty electronic tags
We haven't yet heard of any problems with the RFID tags increasingly being used to monitor inmates in prisons, but it looks like the electronic tags used to keep watch on early release offenders are decidedly less reliable, at least according to a recent investigation into the matter in Scotland. As The Scotsman reports, out of a total of 987 tagging orders issued, there were 285 incidents where the tags failed, with dead batteries the biggest culprit. That rather obvious problem accounted for 185 of the cases, with damage to the unit by the offender, problems with the black box in the offender's home, and a weak signal rounding out the technical difficulties. That, as you might have guessed, has lead some to question the Scottish government's practice of relying on electronic tags to monitor early release offenders, but the government seems to be sticking to its guns, with a spokesman saying that "a breach does not necessarily equate to reoffending," although, as the Scotsman reports, it did recently scrap a plan to tag suspects who were allowed out on bail.[Photo courtesy of The Daily Mail]




















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
KarlW @ Dec 31st 2007 11:35AM
It's a pretty lame idea - all you'd need to do would be to case the antenna part in a metal enclosure. It would act as a faraday cage, and you'd get no signal.
That's if you can't do the obvious and take it off.
drakono @ Dec 31st 2007 11:52AM
And if the battery can go dead 20% of the time, I wonder if (in the event the ideas you mentioned don't work) you can perform some sort of attack to drain the battery -- e.g., constantly requesting the ID from the tag. That should drain it fast, then you're free to wander.
sherryfriedrichs @ Dec 31st 2007 11:50AM
I often wondered if you could short it out with a magnet or some metal device.
drakono @ Dec 31st 2007 11:57AM
Maybe the makers of the device purposely released this story to get feedback on how people might try to break it.
Maybe the released criminals purposely released this story to get ideas on how to try to break it.
:)
NHAnimator @ Dec 31st 2007 11:57AM
Clearly, the RFID tags were not made in Scotland. If it's not Scottish, it's crap!
tiuk @ Dec 31st 2007 3:01PM
As soon as the signal is lost aren't they supposed to go to the person's last known location?
Halfmad @ Dec 31st 2007 3:17PM
Lock them up, good god it's not like we don't have the empty space in Scotland. Hell they'd even have such a nice view front window they wouldn't need a console or a DVD player like they get in most prisons these days, might actually save money running around after all these faulty tags..
thnidu @ Dec 31st 2007 7:07PM
"That, as you might have guessed, has lead some to question..." What's lead got to do with it? "... has led some to question..."